
How Sense Naturals Got 35% of First-Time Buyers to Subscribe
Sense Naturals had a product customers came back for, but its subscription program wasn’t turning that demand into consistent growth. Our agency connected the brand’s website, email, and paid ads around the subscription experience. Sense Naturals reported that 35% of first-time buyers subscribed on their first order.

Story at a Glance
- Starting Point
- Loyal repeat buyers, but little guidance on why shoppers might choose a subscription.
- The Work
- A rebuilt homepage, founder and customer story ads, and purchase-based email.
- The Result
- 35% of first-time buyers subscribed on their first order.
Key Results
01THE PROBLEM
“Customers come back for our product, but we haven’t found a consistent way to turn that demand into subscriptions.”
02THE BUSINESS
The Business
Sense Naturals is a wellness brand that sells supplements for digestive health. It had a small, active subscriber base and loyal customers who returned to buy again. The next opportunity was to make subscribing a clearer option for new shoppers and give existing subscribers a reason to stay.
03THE CHALLENGE
The Challenge
Shoppers could buy once or subscribe, but the website gave them little guidance on why they might choose a subscription. After checkout, the brand also lacked a clear plan for helping new subscribers get started or introducing subscriptions to customers who already knew the product.
A first-time shopper needed to understand the product and what a subscription involved. A returning customer already knew the product and needed a reason to make it part of their routine.
04THE APPROACH
The Approach
Our agency focused on giving customers the information they needed to subscribe when they were ready. We rebuilt the homepage to explain who the product was for, how to use it, and what subscribing offered. Paid ads introduced the product through stories from the founders and customers. Ads for shoppers closer to buying made the subscription offer clear.
After checkout, we tailored emails to how each customer had purchased. New subscribers received help managing their subscription and getting started with the product. Customers who returned for a second order received an invitation to subscribe once they had experience with the product.
We also reviewed renewal behaviour and found that the fourth billing cycle was the biggest point of subscriber drop-off. That gave Sense Naturals a specific renewal to focus on.
05THE RESULTS
The Results
- More than one in three first-time buyers subscribed. Sense Naturals reported a 35% first-order subscription rate.
- Paid ads held attention longer. The share of viewers who continued watching rose from 7% to 24%. The cost per unique outbound click dropped from $12.60 to about $1.
- Subscribers who passed the fourth billing cycle tended to stay. Sense Naturals reported strong retention beyond that point, giving the brand a reason to focus on helping subscribers reach that renewal.
06RELEVANT SUPPORT PATH
Give Repeat Buyers a Clear Path to Subscribe
Sense Naturals already had customers who wanted to buy again. The opportunity was to understand when those customers were ready to subscribe and what they needed to stay.
If customers are buying again but subscription growth is uneven, our agency can help you identify where shoppers hesitate and improve how your website, email, and ads support their next step.
Explore our agency services.
07GLOSSARY
- First-order subscription rate
- The percentage of first-time buyers who start a subscription on their first order.
- Subscriber retention
- How well a business keeps subscribers active over time.
- Billing cycle
- The interval between recurring subscription charges.
Related article: Essential Ecommerce Email Flows
08MORE STORIES
More Merchant Stories


Paraphrase Grew Monthly Revenue by Over 167% With Founder-Led Video Ads
09NEXT STEPS
Your Next Step Toward Shopify Growth
How It Works
Unsure if this is the right fit? Find your brand’s stage in the 5 Stages of Growth.
Find Your StageWe'll make it worth your time.
Ready to talk about your Shopify store and what's next?
Book a Call