
Leveraging AI to Test New Ad Creative at Pirate’s Grog
Pirate’s Grog had plenty of Meta ad data. The harder part was deciding what to test next. Our agency used Motion, an AI-powered ad analytics tool, to compare hooks, formats, and offers and develop new ad ideas based on what was already performing well.

Story at a Glance
- Starting Point
- Plenty of Meta ad data, but no clear way to decide what to test next.
- The Work
- Ads grouped in Motion, compared in context, and AI-assisted hook variations.
- The Result
- A discovery ad that reached 67,144 people at £0.18 per link click.
Key Results
01THE PROBLEM
“We can see which ads perform well. We need a clearer way to decide what to test next.”
02THE BUSINESS
The Business
Pirate’s Grog sells rum online and uses paid social ads to introduce shoppers to the brand, show them what it’s like to order, and give existing customers reasons to come back. A discovery ad, a seasonal unboxing video, and an offer for returning customers each have a different job.
03THE CHALLENGE
The Challenge
Meta’s reporting gave the team the numbers, but comparing ads meant going back and forth between the metrics and the creative itself. A strong ad raised a practical question. Was the opening drawing people in, was the format holding their attention, or was the offer giving them a reason to buy?
The team needed a way to compare ads in context, explain the findings to the client, and turn those observations into ideas it could test.
04THE APPROACH
The Approach
Our agency grouped ads in Motion so the team could see the video, headline, and copy alongside the performance data. That made it easier to compare ads with similar jobs. For example, the team looked at which openings and formats drew interest in discovery ads, then used earlier creative to inform a seasonal unboxing video that showed shoppers what they could expect from an order.
The team also compared spend, purchase value, and acquisition cost across top ads. Once it had a creative direction, it used Motion’s AI tools to suggest alternative hooks and develop ideas the team could produce on a tight timeline. Those suggestions gave the team specific variations to test.
05THE RESULTS
The Results
- The discovery ad reached 67,144 people, with a 2.47% link click-through rate. It cost £0.18 per link click and £4.40 per 1,000 impressions.
- One ad stood out across three purchase measures. Among the three top creatives shown in the report, the leading ad had the highest spend and purchase value while maintaining the lowest cost per acquisition.
- Reporting gave the team a starting point for its next tests. The agency could show the client the ads alongside their results, then use the same comparisons to develop new hooks and creative variations.
06RELEVANT SUPPORT PATH
Give Your Next Ad a Clear Starting Point
If your reports tell you which ads won but leave you wondering what to make next, start by looking at what those ads were designed to do. Our agency helps brands connect creative reporting to the decisions that shape their next round of paid social ads.
Explore our agency services.
07GLOSSARY
- Hook
- The opening line or visual that gives someone a reason to keep watching.
- Link click-through rate (CTR)
- The percentage of ad impressions that resulted in a link click.
- Cost per acquisition (CPA)
- Ad spend divided by the number of attributed acquisitions.
08MORE STORIES
More Merchant Stories


How Sense Naturals Got 35% of First-Time Buyers to Subscribe
09NEXT STEPS
Your Next Step Toward Shopify Growth
How It Works
Unsure if this is the right fit? Find your brand’s stage in the 5 Stages of Growth.
Find Your StageWe'll make it worth your time.
Ready to talk about your Shopify store and what's next?
Book a Call